忍者ブログ

From New Zealand 2007年7月,ニュージーランドへ移住してきました。ニュージーランドでの日常生活についてつづります。

RSS TWITTER RssTwitter

[PR]

×

[PR]上記の広告は3ヶ月以上新規記事投稿のないブログに表示されています。新しい記事を書く事で広告が消えます。

ネイティブチェック33

I don’t like oranges. / I don’t eat oranges. / They don’t sell oranges. は無冠詞複数名詞でOK。
でも,I don’t have dogs.やI’ve never made speeches.の無冠詞複数名詞に違和感あるのはなぜ?
という疑問について,以下ネイティブの解説。

Let's change it to 'children'.
 
'I don't have any children.'
--- Most people consider that two or three kids is a normal family unit, so since the topic is the number of children, the negative plural is correct.

 
'I don't have a child.'
--- The negative singular would be appropriate in China, where most people have only one child.

 
'I don't have children.'
--- This would suggest that the topic is not 'how many', but 'what', and that the speaker has something other than children.
A mother frustrated at her messy children might declare, 'I don't have children - I have bloody animals!'

Now, 'They (don't) sell oranges' - answers a 'what' question.
'I have never made speeches' also answers a what question ('I've made presentations to small groups, but I've never made speeches').
However, if someone asks 'How many speeches have you made to date?' you could answer, 'I've never made any speeches' or 'I've never made a speech (in my life)!' for emphasis (= 'I've never made even a single one'). Ditto for 'English speeches'.
 
PR
Comment
name
title
color
mail
URL
comment
pass   Vodafone絵文字 i-mode絵文字 Ezweb絵文字
コメントの修正にはpasswordが必要です。任意の英数字を入力して下さい。
この記事へのトラックバック
この記事にトラックバックする:
Clear